2014年4月29日星期二

The shifts in management education

Introduction

During the past decades, globalization brings opportunity as well as enormous pressure for the corporations to strive for its survival and growth. One of the key determinants to survive and strive is knowledge management and how to equip its management with updated concepts and skills. A firm’s competitive advantage depends more than anything on its knowledge: on what it knows, how it uses what it knows and how fast it can learn something new (HR Magazine, 2009, p. 1).Management education becomes one of the most important and prevailing way for company to gain knowledge since the first MBA School in 1900. However, through the evolution through one century, today’s management education changes a lot from the earlier as the needs of the students and company shift.

Shift from mastery of theories to mastery of skills

According Pfeffer & Fong (2002), research showed that the curriculum of the management education was too focused on analytics, with insufficient emphasis on problem finding as contrasted with problem solving and implementation. Also, there is not much evidence that the mastery of business concept could make the graduates advance their careers in today’s complex business environments. The driving forces to change are imperative, especially in the 21st century, the market forces like globalization, technological advancement, cross cultural diversity and etc.

To cope with the challenging environment in the global village, a company should have “the competitive advantage, it depends more than anything on its knowledge” (HR Magazine, 2009, p. 1). Davenport pointed out “knowledge management system requires that information be useful, timely, and accurate” (Davenport, p. 24).  

We believe that the management education is essential and important for the sustainability of an organization and individual in the complex business environment.  Therefore, we have seen that in the early stage, the collaborative practice of the business schools are the students and professors but now also including the private or public organizations.

Networking

For studying the management education programs, like a MBA degree course, it is not only to impart management education to an individual but also impart a symbolic status to him or her to build a social network in the business environment. It is said that globalization has further strengthen the social network into a global network of the students of management education.  Classmates would interact with diverse groups, executives from various industries, functions & region, share experience and insights in various perspectives; so as alumni and the faculty – to build a new network for the possibility of future collaboration, it’s admitted that once admitted by a school, the alumni identity accompanies whole life.

Culture: an emergent topic

Also, with the increasing trend of doing business across the globe, the diversify culture among countries is a challenge to the organizations and individuals. The management education program should also implant the culture issues into various core courses, like marketing management, communication skills and business ethics.

Ethics education becomes prevailing  
After financial crisis in 2008, public awareness of corporate integrity was highly increased. Stakeholders now see boards as more accountable for the effectiveness of their overall governance process (Delotte, 2013). “Company fosters a trusting culture will have an advantage in the war of talent” (Hurley, 2006). The change of business practice put a pressure on the management school redesign the curriculum in ethical development of their students.

The management schools are required to persuade the employer that their students are educated with business ethics and behave ethically. There are six fundamental principles of persuasion (Cialdini, 2001) and management schools are using Liking, Consistency, Authority and Scarcity for persuasion. Management schools are also required to work closely with industries and corporation to maintain the quality of education (Gupta, 2011). They need to regularly review their curriculum and bring necessary change according to the needs of the corporation and environment.

It is showed there are many strategic partnerships between corporations and management school to increase the value add to the distribution role in the industry (Paul et al, 2003). For example, Management schools invited guest speakers, business managers or religious leader to deliver seminars and class. However, strategic partnership between corporations and management school on ethics education is limited. To cater complex world and demand for ethics education, collaboration between the consulting firm and management schools on the business ethics researches and development of education program me is expected.

Conclusion


Collaboration is about bringing ideas together, about sharing perspectives and insight and effort, for the purpose of getting useful thing done. Company and schools are the main character in management education. Schools have to adapt its curriculum to changing business environment and in return, companies supply ideas and practice for schools to deliver knowledge more effectively to the students. It’s also time for the corporation to partner with university to achieve synergy to deliver the essence of good management education and train people for managerial positions.


Reference
1.        Watson, W. E., (2009) Leveraging HR and Knowledge management in a challenging economy, HR magazine
2.        Tapscott, D, Erickson, T, Gratton, L, Cross, R and Cap, F (2009) Building the Collaborative Enterprise. Ten questions to ask about business opportunities though collaboration. nGenera Corporation.
3.        Delotte (2013) Developing effective governance operating model: A guide for financial services boards and management teams
4.        Hurley, R. F. (2006) Managing yourself: The decision to trust. Harvard Business Review, September, 55-62
5.        Cialdini, Robert B. (2001) Harnessing the science of persuasion, Harvard Business Review, 79(9)
6.        Paul N. F., Betts R. A. and Sullivan R. S. (2003) Changes in graduate management education and new business school strategies for the 21th century. Academy of Management Learning & Education 2(3), 233-24
7.        Gupta, R (2011) Paradigm shift in management education: The need of the hour. International Journal of Enterprise Computing and Business System Vol. 1 Issue 2 July
8.        Jeffrey Pfeffer & Christina T. Fong (2002, September).  The End of Business Schools? Less Success Than Meets the Eye.  Academy of Management Learning & Education Vol. 1, Number 1. Retrieved 17 April 2014 https://www.aomonline.org/Publications/Articles/BSchools.asp
9.        Rex Davenport (2005, February).  Why Does Knowledge Management Still Matter?  T+D American Society for Training & Development.


2014年4月13日星期日

the changing role of management education

In the past, when we talked about management, normally in our perception, it refers to business and cooperation and while speaking of education, it’s more about research, theories and serious scholars. These 2 words seem quite separate from each other, but as society developing and changing, the 2 converged as management education.
We tried to find the formal definition but failed, maybe just because the role of management education is always changing. Or maybe even Google feels reluctant to define because the role of it changes in the every minute. We identified several changes occurring and later in our group and individual blog we will explain and analyze why it changes

·      The content ( From theory introduction to skills application)
For example let’s say in China, students used to be work separately but now team study is more prevailing. Because as the more and more companies realized cooperation is inevitable within organization, professors can’t merely describe team building theories like (forming, storming norming, performing) to help the students experience cooperation. We have to form team randomly or force to form by teacher, at least we should learn through our own experience on how to cooperate. Apart from that, cooperation sometimes cooperate with universities to develop tailored education for employee, it’s like a synergy for both parties, since for universities they need real case for further study and for company they need universities to address the needs on knowledge and culture. (Like the cooperation between VTC and company)

·        
    The management education is to help the managers of an organization to deal with the complex business environment. To make an organization with sustainable long term development, the managers should have the skills to cope with the rapid changing of the global business environment. Therefore, the historical perspective of management education should shift to more diversify training method.
 Past
Traditionally the management education is only concentrated on:
- Mastery of business concepts” e.g. accounting, finance, marketing, human resources and operations management & etc.
-Case Studies
-Through Lecture / Video Clips
non-traditional-study-abroad-students.jpg
Now
To develop the mindsets & skills needed to integrate “sustainability” into an organization’s strategy and operations
-Case Studies / Real Life Situations
-Interactive and Strengthen in Communication Skills
-Through Lectures, Movies/Video Clips 
-Projects in association with industries and companies
e.g. Hong Kong University of Science & Technology
http://www.bm.ust.hk/execed/com_img/hkusst_logo.gif 
Company Programs are based on the knowledge that every organization has its own strategies, culture and developmental challenges. Our experts work with companies to tailor programs to meet their specific requirements, calling on the Business School's expertise and our own relationships in the business community.
The Bank of China (Hong Kong)
The Bank of China (Hong Kong), a long-standing learning partner, believes talent can be developed by tailoring training objectives.
"The Business School was able to customize its executive programs to match our requirements. The faculties' commitment to that end and their interactive teaching approach left an unforgettable impression on participants who gained advanced management knowledge in a comfortable and interesting environment."
Tuanjie Huo, Former General Manager, Human Resources, Bank of China (Hong Kong) 
Shift from the historical to current perspectives 
Development 
1)     Global Vision  
Organizations should learn the diversity culture of the globe in order to have sustainable development of their businesses, therefore, with a world vision and knowledge, like MBA program, it is said to be crucial for an organization's managerial people.
Harvard Business School (Financial Times - Global MBA Ranking No.1 in 2013)  
harvard.png
harvard 1.jpg
2) Role of Management Education
With the term of "global village", it is said that the business environment is becoming more complex, the business schools should develop an in-depth understanding of the global businesses.  
Hong Kong University of Science & Technology Business School
(Financial Times - Global MBA Ranking No.10 in 2013) 


 
3)     Networking 
Interact with diverse groups, executives from various industries, functions & region.  Classmates would share experience and insights in various perspectives; so as alumni and the faculty – to build a new network for the possibility of future collaboration. 
e.g. University of Hong Kong Science & Technology
Willpower of 2 EMBA alumni of HKUST
HKUST.jpg

                  Networking also counts

Once admitted by a school, the alumni identity accompanies whole life. Admit or not, the alumni identity can easily unfreeze the stranger’s ice immediately. It helps you enlarge your social net and the similar experience become the first facilitator to build trust. It doesn’t matter what you learned, it matters who you know.as the old saying points out.
·         The influence of Symbol
You won’t recognize luxury value its price unless you find its symbol for status. The same with education, most people can’t value education unless they feel the privilege education provided. HR added value for education through put education requirements on job requirements

we will introduce more information about what drives the change internally and externally in our coming group blog and individual blog. 





References:


www.study2u.com/blog/on-line-degress/benefits (retrieved 11 April 2014)


Hong Kong University of Science & Technology,

http://www.bm.ust.hk/execed/company_programs/overview.html (retrieved 12 April 2014)